The debate highlighted the role of credibility in science from "summary" of Leviathan and the Air-Pump by Steven Shapin,Simon Schaffer
The debate over the merits of Hobbesian and Boylean approaches to knowledge production brought to the forefront the critical issue of credibility in the practice of science. Both parties sought to establish their credibility by employing different methods and criteria. Hobbes emphasized the importance of authority and reputation in determining the veracity of scientific claims. He argued that the credibility of a statement derived from the credibility of the person making it – a position that drew on traditional modes of knowledge production prevalent in the seventeenth century. In contrast, Boyle advocated for the experimental method as the primary means of establishing credibility in scient...
Similar Posts
Intuitions can be valuable but also biased
Intuitions are judgments that come to mind quickly and without much effort. They are often based on personal experiences and fe...
Modern humans have conquered the world through their cognitive abilities
One of the key factors that set Homo sapiens apart from other species is our ability to think and communicate in complex ways. ...
Students are encouraged to think critically and analytically
The concept of encouraging students to think critically and analytically is fundamental in the field of education. By fostering...
Despite the difficulties, they persevered in their mission
Despite the many obstacles that stood in their way, the individuals involved in this ambitious project did not waver in their d...
Navigating the complexities of theoretical physics
The task of understanding theoretical physics is not for the faint-hearted. It requires a keen intellect, a sharp eye for detai...
Collaboration is crucial for the advancement of knowledge
The generation of knowledge is not a solitary pursuit. It is not the work of one individual, toiling away in isolation, that mo...
Science offers a way to understand the world
Science, with its rigorous methodology and reliance on evidence, provides a powerful framework for understanding the world arou...