Shapin and Schaffer analyze the social dynamics of knowledge production from "summary" of Leviathan and the Air-Pump by Steven Shapin,Simon Schaffer

In the study of the social dynamics of knowledge production, Shapin and Schaffer delve into the intricate relationships between scientists, their experiments, and the broader social context in which knowledge is created. They argue that scientific knowledge is not solely the result of individual genius or objective observation, but rather emerges through a complex interplay of social, political, and cultural influences. By examining the case of Robert Boyle and Thomas Hobbes in the seventeenth century, Shapin and Schaffer demonstrate how scientific knowledge is shaped by power dynamics, social hierarchies, and competing ideologies. Boyle's experimental approach to natural philosophy, as exemplified in his air-pump experiments, was not just a matter of objective inquiry, but also a means of asserting his authority and challenging the philosophical views of his contemporary, Hobbes. The authors show how Boyle strategically presented his experiments to gain credibility and legitimacy within the scientific community, using rhetoric, persuasion, and social networks to shape the interpretation and reception of his findings. In contrast, Hobbes' more skeptical and politically charged view of science reflected his own philosophical commitments and social position, highlighting the role of ideology in shaping scientific knowledge. Through their analysis, Shapin and Schaffer reveal the complex ways in which scientific knowledge is produced, contested, and legitimized within specific social contexts. They challenge the notion of science as a purely objective and universal enterprise, emphasizing instead the contingent and socially constructed nature of knowledge production.

Their study highlights the importance of considering the social dynamics of knowledge production in understanding the history of science and the ways in which power, ideology, and social relations shape scientific practice and discourse.

Open in app

The road to your goals is in your pocket! Download the Oter App to continue reading your Microbooks from anywhere, anytime.

Leviathan and the Air-Pump

Steven Shapin

Open in app

Now you can listen to your microbooks on-the-go. Download the Oter App on your mobile device and continue making progress towards your goals, no matter where you are.